What We Still Don’t Know About Sunscreens: A Running Debate

As I mentioned in my last post, about the only thing that seems to have changed with respect to the state of sunscreens and sun safety products is that the mainstream media is starting to pay more attention to this issue and take a frank look at what needs to be done.

The New York Times appears to have taken the lead here with its recent Room for Debate blog: What We Still Don’t Know About Sunscreens. In Room for Debate, The Times invites knowledgeable outside contributors to discuss news events and other timely issues. For this conversation, the Times convened the following contributors:

  • Darrell S. Rigel, Clinical Professor of Dermatology
  • Sonya Lunder, Environmental Working Group
  • Michael K. Hansen, Consumers Union
  • Kerry Hanson, Chemist, University of California, Riverside
  • Lenora Felderman, Dermatologist

Darrell Rigel tackles the subject of better labeling and better ingredients. Apparently in the U.S. there are only 17 approved sunscreen agents, while Europe has 28, and Japan has more than 40. He blames the FDA for lagging in formally approving regulations and feels that rather than wait until they can come up with their own standards for testing UVA that we simply adopt the same standards as Europe has.

Sonya Lunder looks at an alarming new finding: the use of Vitamin A (in the synthetic form of Retinyl Palmitate) in sun care products may be accelerating the development of skin lesions and tumors when applied in the presence of sunlight! According to Lunder, this ingredient can be found in a whopping 40% (almost half!) of sunscreens used in the U.S.

Michael Hansen takes the FDA to task for not being more aggressive in demanding and enforcing the use of warnings on product labels that would clarify which products provide actual protect against UVA. A product may have a high SPF which means it protects against UVB radiation but that doesn’t mean it protects against UVA. He also feels that the FDA should more thoroughly investigate the health concerns that have been raised about various sunscreen ingredients.

Kerry Hanson questions whether our current concept of sun care protection needs to be redefined given what we’ve learned about the difference between UVB and UVA exposures and their respective roles in causing or promoting skin cancer. Since companies don’t have the substantial resources needed to fund the research (or the proper impartiality), there’s an opportunity for government agencies like the FDA, National Science Foundation, and the NIH to jump in and take the lead.

Lenora Felderman laments the false sense of security that sunscreens provide and echoes the other contributors’ call for better and more responsible action by the FDA.

Since it was posted on July 5th, this has generated over 200 comments. You can read the full discussions here and add your comments as well.

What do you think the FDA’s top priorities in this area should be?

Possible 75% cancer mortality reduction with Vitamin D

Too good to be true? Check out this video from the University of California TV where they interview Dr. Cedric F. Garland from the University of California San Diego School of Medicine on his ground-breaking research findings about Vitamin D’s role in preventing major cancers. If this doesn’t convince you of the importance of Vitamin D to your health I’m not sure what will!

Exposure to the Sun May Give You Skin Cancer But Vitamin D Can Save Your Life!

Sun exposure offers us many health benefits: it provides us with a natural high by stimulating the release of feel-good substances in the body –seratonin, dopamine, and beta-endorphins. Sunshine also suppresses hormones such as melatonin that makes you feel sluggish and down. And, as I mentioned in my last post, it’s your best source of Vitamin D.

The importance of Vitamin D as a vital and protective nutrient cannot be underestimated. Its role in reducing mortality rates in cancer patients is starting to make many in the medical community question the conventional wisdom about sun safety and weigh the considerable benefits of sun exposure against the potential risk of skin cancer.

This short but informative video summarizes some key points on this subject:

Protect Your Skin from the Inside Out: Antioxidants to Counteract the Effects of Sun Damage

There’s no shortage of dire warnings about the damaging and cancer-causing potential of unprotected exposure to the sun. While sunscreens and sun blocks do provide protection from sunburn (UVB exposure) and arguably some protection from the long-term effects of UVA exposure, a number of factors can diminish their effectiveness and there’s some cause for concern about the accuracy of SPF ratings. As if that weren’t bad enough, now many doctors are warning that over-use of sunscreens impedes your body’s natural ability to synthesize Vitamin D –a vital nutrient that can protect you from other common cancers like prostate, breast, and colon cancer.

But it’s not all bad news out there. There is one promising area of research that doesn’t receive much attention from the media, but may hold the key to protecting your self and your loved ones from the damaging effects of UV radiation. There’s plenty of evidence to suggest that a diet low in saturated or trans fats, supplemented with certain foods and nutrients rich in select vitamins and antioxidants can also help protect your skin from the inside out.

Even better, preliminary and ongoing research indicates that many of the antioxidants found in vitamins and botanicals when added to sunscreens AND taken orally — significantly boost the skin’s natural UV-filtering properties while enhancing its defenses against free radical formation.

Here’s how it works … prolonged exposure to sunlight, especially ultraviolet (UV) wavelengths, can induce the formation of Reactive Oxygen Species (ROS), the most potent of which are free radicals that can cause genetic DNA mutations. These DNA-damaged cells then become the precursors for cancerous tumors. An antioxidant-rich diet can neutralize free radicals, counteract the sun’s damaging effects, and in some cases even reverse it.

Most of these protective vitamins, minerals, and other nutrients are readily available in the foods you already eat. The ones holding the most promise are Vitamins C and E, the mineral Selenium, and carotenoids like Beta Carotene (the natural form of vitamin A and the source of color in carrots) and Lycopene (the carotenoid that gives foods like tomatoes, watermelon, pink grapefruit, and guava their red and pink color).

While not necessarily antioxidants, Zinc, Copper and Manganese are minerals that support the process of neutralizing free radicals. Glutathione-rich foods like asparagus, avocado, garlic, parsley, acorn squash, zucchini, tomatoes, can also protect the body from carcinogens.

Skin Cancer Detection: How to Check Yourself for Skin Cancer

Examining your self for skin cancer sounds like a pretty easy and straightforward thing to do and yet I bet most people don’t even give it a second thought unless they have a family history of skin cancer and therefore a reason for concern.

Given how important it is to protect yourself from the potentially fatal outcome of developing Melanoma, I wanted to share this simple but practical video I found that goes through the basics of self-examination, so you don’t omit any important areas. It also offers some tips on documenting anything you find that might turn ugly later on. After watching this you’ll want to include a regular self-exam into your health and wellness routine. If you can, enlist the help of a family member or friend to examine and document hose areas of your body that are hard to see by yourself (mainly your back side and your scalp).

Skin Cancer Detection: The ABCD Method

The ABCD Rule is a guideline developed by the American Cancer Society to help you identify some of the usual signs of melanoma. Protect yourself and your loved ones by examining and getting to know your skin on a regular basis.

Becoming familiar with your skin and its various bumps, lesions, or other peculiarities can help you quickly identify anything new or unusual, as well as notable changes in existing moles or lesions. Notify your health practitioner if you notice any of the following kinds of skin developments:

A stands for ASYMMETRY: One half of a mole or birthmark doesn’t match the other

B stands for BORDER: The edges are irregular, ragged, notched or blurred

C is for COLOR: The color is not the same all over, but may have different shades of brown or black, sometimes with patches of red, white or blue

D is for DIAMETER: The area is larger than 6 millimeters (about ¼ inch or the size of a pencil eraser) or is growing larger.

Some explanations of the ABCD method include an E at the end (i.e. ABCDE). This fifth letter stands for EVOLUTION which refers to perhaps the most important warning sign for melanoma skin cancer: a spot on the skin that is changing in size, shape, or color over a period of one month to 1-2 years.

For some additional helpful (though not pleasant to look at) visuals check out this WebMD slideshow.

Skin Cancer & Sun Damage: What You Really Need to Know

The prospect of getting skin cancer is frightening for anyone. If the prognoses of doctors, dermatologists, beauty magazines and the media in general are to be believed, everyone is at risk. And yet, there’s no hard scientific evidence that this is true. In fact, there’s a growing consensus in the medical community that the anti-sun rhetoric that’s had everyone slathering on sunscreen every time they step outside, has been over-stated.

It helps to know as much as you can to make an educated guess as to the best options for minimizing the risk for yourself and your loved ones. Here’s a summary of what I know now (and you should too):

  • Exposure to the sun without any form of protection leads to sunburn from UVB radiation. The more sunburns you get the greater your likelihood of developing skin cancer.
  • Sunburns and UVB radiation were considered to be the primary risk factor for skin cancer but now evidence suggests that UVA radiation plays a much bigger role in both skin cancer and premature aging.
  • Until recently, most sunscreens were developed to either physically block or chemically disperse UVB rays. Though many sun protection products have been reformulated to include some UVA protection the only ingredients that are known to be photo stable and effectively block out both types of UV rays are Titanium Dioxide and Zinc Oxide in the form of sun blocks.
  • UVB radiation is the way that our bodies utilize solar energy to convert it into vitamin D, which has been studied and found to be a key nutrient for keeping bones and teeth strong. A deficiency in vitamin D has been linked to other types of cancer including breast, prostate and colon cancers. Overuse of sunscreens blocks our bodies’ ability to synthesize this vital nutrient.
  • There is sufficient evidence to indicate that a variety of antioxidants that when taken both orally via diet & supplementation, and topically can significantly reduce the damaging effects of UV radiation.
  • There are three types of skin cancer: Basal Cell, Squamous Cell, and Melanoma. Basal Cell is the most common of skin cancers and it’s the most easily treated and least likely to spread. Squamous cell is also easily treated if detected early, but it’s slightly more apt to spread. Melanoma is the most serious form of skin cancer and the one responsible for the most skin cancer deaths because of how rapidly it spreads.
  • Basal Cell and Squamous Cell carcinomas typically appear on those parts of your body that are most often exposed to the sun –your face, ears, neck, lips, hands, arms, chest or back.
  • Melanoma most often appears on the trunk, head or neck of affected men. In women it most often develops on the arms or legs. In either gender it can appear in areas of the body that are never exposed to the sun.
  • Your skin type, as well as hereditary risk factors, along with poor nutrition and a weak immune system, play a greater role in your likelihood of developing skin cancer. People most at risk include those with freckles, fair skin tones, light colored eyes (green or blue), and naturally red or blonde hair. Others also at greater risk are those who burn easily, spend a lot of time outdoors, or have a personal or family history of skin cancer or melanoma.

FDA-Approved Sunscreen Ingredients: Do You Really Want to Put These on Your Skin?

According to The Chemical Sunscreen Health Disaster site, chemical sunscreens are potentially harmful to humans in one of two ways: 1) their chemical action leads to the proliferation of cancer-causing free radicals and/or 2) their estrogenic effects make them endocrine disruptors which can cause serious problems in sexual development and adult sexual function, and can further increase risks for certain types of cancer other than melanoma.

The results of one study done at the Institute of Pharmacology and Toxicology at the University of Zurich, Switzerland, showed that many widely used sunscreen chemicals, including benzophenone-3, octyl methoxycinnamate, and octyl-dimethyl-PABA, mimic the effects of the female hormone estrogen and trigger developmental abnormalities in rats.

As far back as 1998, Dr. John Knowland at the University of Oxford, reported studies showing that certain sunscreens containing PABA and its derivatives can damage DNA, at least in the test tube experiments. When a chemical sunscreen, Padimate-O, was added to DNA and the mixture exposed to the ultraviolet rays of sunlight, it was found that the sunscreen broke down in sunlight, releasing highly active agents that could damage DNA.

Research by the Environmental Working Group (EWG) of over 1,500 sunscreens and other sun-blocking products currently on the market found that 3 of 5 sunscreens either don’t protect skin from sun damage or contain hazardous chemicals – or both. Their 2009 Sunscreen Report found a 70% increase over 2008 in the number of products containing one ore more of the 4 strong UVA filters FDA has approved for use in sunscreens (Avobenzone, Mexoryl, Titanium Dioxide, and Zinc).

Their research showed that despite the increased use of UVA filters, 1-in-9 products offer dangerously low levels of UVA protection. In August 2007, the FDA proposed a 4-star rating system for UVA protection and a requirement that the rating appear on sunscreen labels. The FDA has not finalized this proposal, and no brands are posting the new UVA rating voluntarily. With no mandatory, comprehensive sunscreen standards in place, products vary widely in safety and effectiveness. Check out the chart in the EWG Report that illustrates how most products that are effective or moderately effective at protecting you from sun damage, also pose a moderate-to-high health hazard.

Your tax dollars hard at work …

Copyright 2009 Dropwise Essentials

WANT TO USE THIS ARTICLE IN YOUR EZINE OR WEB SITE?You can, as long as you include this complete blurb with it: Donya Fahmy, is a green business owner and the creator of Dropwise Essentials’ spa-quality aromatherapy body products that help you safely relieve stress, increase vitality, improve confidence, or simply manage your emotional state any time or place without popping a pill. For more free tips and valuable information visit www.dropwise.com and subscribe to the Dropwise Health & Beauty News Ezine or blog feed.

FDA-Approved Sunscreen Ingredients: Do They Cause More Harm Than Good?

Here’s the list of FDA-approved sunscreen ingredients I’ve compiled so far (if I missed anything obvious, feel free to comment below):

Avobenzone (also known as Parsol 1789)
Cinoxate
Dioxybenzone
Homosalate
Menthyl anthranilate
Mexoryl
Octinoxate (formerly Octyl Methoxycinnamate)
Octocrylene
Octyl Salicylate
Oxybenzone
Padimate O
Phenylbenzimidazole sulfonic acid
Sulisobenzone
Titanium Dioxide
Trolamine salicylate
Zinc Oxide

Of this list, only two ingredients —Titanium Dioxide and Zinc Oxide— are naturally occurring ingredients. Both are very effective physical UVA and UVB sun blocks because they deflect UV rays away from the skin. All the other ingredients are chemical sunscreens that work by absorbing UVB radiation (the so-called “burning rays”) and then dispersing the energy through chemical reactions –some of which can generate those dreaded “free radicals” that lead to cancer. Free radicals are unstable molecules that cause cellular damage by stealing electrons from healthy cells –a process called oxidation.
The most commonly used of these ingredients are Avobenzone, Octinoxate (formerly Octyl Methoxycinnamate), Octocrylene, Oxybenzone, and Padimate O.
Avobenzone is an oil soluble chemical agent capable of absorbing light throughout the entire UVA spectrum. It is one of the very few comprehensive chemical UVA sunscreens available on the market right now. Its role in protecting skin from the potentially carcinogenic effects of UVA radiation, are what make it the most widely used chemical sunscreen ingredient and the only one approved by the European Union.
Unfortunately, Avobenzone is known in the scientific community as a strong free radical generator that degrades fairly quickly in actual sunlight, rapidly reducing its effectiveness as a sunscreen. Which has to make you wonder … can using this type of sunscreen actually cause more harm than good?

Copyright 2009 Dropwise Essentials

WANT TO USE THIS ARTICLE IN YOUR EZINE OR WEB SITE? You can, as long as you include this complete blurb with it: Donya Fahmy, is a green business owner and the creator of Dropwise Essentials’ spa-quality aromatherapy body products that help you safely relieve stress, increase vitality, improve confidence, or simply manage your emotional state any time or place without popping a pill. For more free tips and valuable information visit www.dropwise.com and subscribe to the Dropwise Health & Beauty News Ezine or blog feed.

Overexposed: Tips for Staying Sun Safe in the Dog Days of Summer

As a formulator and manufacturer of all natural plant-based personal care products, I often get asked if any Dropwise products contain sunscreens. The answer is no. Sunscreens are considered over-the-counter drugs regulated by the FDA, and except for two ingredients, all the sunscreen ingredients currently approved by the FDA are synthetic chemicals –some of which are known to be irritants and toxic.

I’ve researched sun care and sunscreens for some time now in the hopes of finding a breakthrough in natural ingredients that could replace the chemical sunscreens that are prevalent in today’s sun care products. While there are promising developments on the horizon and valid science to support them, we are not there yet.

In the past, having a golden tan was a sign of beauty and health, and sun protection was all about maximizing opportunities to tan while avoiding the pain and discomfort of getting burned. Now, valid or not, the consensus among dermatologists and doctors seems to be that any exposure to the sun is harmful and can lead to cancer.

Yet in spite of the proliferation of products with SPF 30 and greater, and the over blown dire warnings not to ever leave your house without sunscreen, the incidence of skin cancer in the U.S. continues to grow at an alarming rate. So how can you find out what your true risk is?

There are many factors that determine your risk level including what your skin type is; hereditary factors that could make you more risk-prone; where you live (i.e. altitude and latitude); the amount and type of fats in your diet; whether you are taking certain meds; the time of day and length of exposure; and the biggest predictor of all: how much over-exposure you had as a child and young adult.

If you regularly and religiously apply some form of sunscreen, how much you apply, when, where, and how often all affect the product’s ability to successfully filter out the different ultraviolet (UV) rays that damage skin and can cause skin cancer.

Here’s a quick summary of what you need to know:

UVA vs. UVB Radiation. There’s still a debate over which type of exposure is more harmful. UVB rays are what cause sunburns and are also what your body uses to convert sunlight into Vitamin D. Most sunscreens primarily protect against UVB, which was originally thought to be the main cause of skin cancer. Now there is reason to believe that UVA rays cause more skin damage in the long run and play a larger role in skin cancer. There is currently no standard for formulating “broad spectrum” sunscreens that protect against both. Ironically, the Vitamin D that your body gets from UVB exposure plays a vital role in keeping bones and teeth strong, and helps protect against breast, prostate and colon cancers –making a strong case for a minimal amount of daily unprotected exposure.

Diminishing Returns of Higher SPFs. There’s a lot of confusion over how effective higher value SPFs really are at providing more protection. Most consumers think that stepping up from an SPF 15 to an SPF 30 doubles your protection and the amount of time you can stay in the sun. But in fact, because of the way SPF is calculated, this step up actually offers less than a 4% increase in protection! No SPF will absorb 100% of UV rays, so don’t even bother with any product boasting an SPF higher than 30. There’s also growing concern that the lab testing methods used to establish SPFs are not consistent enough to reflect the vagaries of usage and actual conditions created by real sunlight.

Knowing that SPF values may not be entirely accurate, you shouldn’t rely on sunscreen as the sole method of protecting yourself.

Sunscreen vs. Sunblock. Sunscreens fall into two categories: chemical types and physical types. Chemical sunscreens generally absorb UVB radiation (the so-called “burning rays”) and then disperse that energy through chemical reactions –some of which can actually generate those dreaded “free radicals” that lead to cancer. Physical sunscreens -commonly known as sun blocks-come in the old-fashioned form of titanium dioxide and zinc oxide, white creams that reflect radiation rather than absorb it. Sun blocks are the preferred form of sun protection but because of their texture many consumers don’t like them.

Nanoparticles and Micronization. In an attempt to make traditional sun block ingredients more palatable to the consumer, manufacturers have started to micronize the ingredients so they are readily absorbed into the skin and are no longer visible after application — avoiding the whole pasty white war paint effect that make them so unappealing.

Unfortunately, this use of nanotechnology is currently unregulated and has some potentially serious health consequences. A 2006 Friends of the Earth report on the dangers of nanoparticles in skin and sun care products cited scientific research that showed many nanoparticles to be toxic to human tissue and cell structure. Their presence in the body can lead to oxidative stress, DNA mutation, and free radical generation  –all risk factors for cancer. It’s best to avoid this form of sunscreen and stick to the traditional forms of zinc and titanium dioxide.

Natural vs. Synthetic. In addition to the toxicity posed by some chemical sunscreens, you should be concerned about all the other potentially harmful ingredients contained in many sunscreen products. The question to ask yourself is am I simply trading one poison for another?

Here are some additional tips to help you stay sun safe in the dog days of summer:

  • Whether you use sunscreen or not, avoid prolonged exposure during the peak hours of 10 AM to 2 PM. Limit your initial exposure to shorter stretches (15 to 30 minutes at a time depending on skin type) until you build up a bit of a base tan, then you can gradually increase the amount of exposure.
  • If you’re fair-skinned, wear protective clothing (long sleeves, pants) and a wide-brimmed hat whenever possible, and use a sunblock when in the sun
  • Use a plant-based body oil made with coconut, jojoba, grape seed, rose hip seed, carrot and/or hemp seed oils as a pre-sun and after sun moisturizer. Research shows that moisturizers made with Vitamin E and C can help fight the free radicals produced by sun damage.
  • Increase your intake of antioxidants through food and supplementation. Again, consuming foods that are high in Vitamins A (Beta Carotene), C and E can also help fight free radicals. This is especially important if you spend a lot of time in the sun!
  • Avoid putting citrus essential oils on your skin when going out in the sun as some of them are photo-toxic and can increase your chances of getting burned.
  • Stay hydrated. Drink plenty of water and remember shade is your friend!

Copyright 2009 Dropwise Essentials

WANT TO USE THIS ARTICLE IN YOUR EZINE OR WEB SITE?You can, as long as you include this complete blurb with it: Donya Fahmy, is a green business owner and the creator of Dropwise Essentials’ spa-quality aromatherapy body products that help you safely relieve stress, increase vitality, improve confidence, or simply manage your emotional state any time or place without popping a pill. For more free tips and valuable information visit www.dropwise.com and subscribe to the Dropwise Health & Beauty News Ezine or blog feed.